Colourpop Creme Gel Pencil Swerve
This black pencil liner delivers a consistency like a gel pot, without the hassle. The packaging is also one of the best mechanisms among similar products out there, featuring a smooth glide up. However, this smudges the bottom lids over time and gets hard to draw smoothly if you go without using it for a couple of days. I definitely have used better drugstore eyeliners.